A home warranty is a form of service contract that pays to repair or replace equipment or systems in your house that break down. These contracts are frequently more intricate than they appear and, according to our expert, may occasionally duplicate the coverage that you currently have.
 |
| A Professor of Insurance Law Offers His Opinion on Home Warranties |
Chad Marzen, an American General Insurance Associate Professor of Insurance Law at Florida State University, spoke exclusively to Investopedia about house warranties, including what they cover, how much they cost, and if they are worth considering. The transcript of our chat follows.
What exactly is a house warranty, and what does it cover?
A house warranty is considered a service contract, according to Marzen. If a covered item or system malfunctions, fails or breaks down, an outside company is obligated to offer service or a contractor for service.
A normal house warranty or service contract will cover many of the home's systems and appliances, including your water and power lines, air conditioning system, refrigerator, washing and dryer, and dishwasher.
Outside of the primary appliances, the provider may charge an extra price. Some people attempt to conceal items such as pool awnings, pool enclosures, or a grass sprinkler system. Optional coverage for such products may be provided.
What about utilities that enter or exit the residence but are not owned by the utility company? Is that covered by a house warranty?
In addition to covering eligible appliances, many home warranty organizations will also cover systems linked with the property. Some house warranty providers offer system coverage for systems such as air conditioning and heating, electrical, and plumbing.
However, a buyer should carefully evaluate the coverages for these systems because they only cover specific components of the system and frequently have exceptions. Some home warranty plans incorporate coverage for systems and appliances, while others do not.
A house warranty should not be confused with homeowners insurance. A house warranty protects against system and equipment failure. Insurance protects your house and its contents against liability and calamity.
So, how can you tell the difference between a house warranty and homeowners insurance?
Marzen: Traditionally, homeowners insurance will cover things like a liability. If someone is harmed on your property, for example, homeowners insurance will pay it. Something like that would not be covered by a house warranty. Several state insurance departments regulate homeowners insurance firms.
What Does a Home Warranty Include?
You've supplied a list of eligible appliances and systems; assuming that the more items covered, the more costly the coverage, what are the most critical things that consumers should protect with a house warranty?
The highest-value objects in the home are the most significant to the ordinary customer. As an example, consider the air conditioning or heating system. Replacement will normally cost several thousand dollars, if not more, depending on the system and whether it is divided or one unit.
Many businesses provide service plans and warranties. It is critical to acquire a warranty, especially if you have an older device that may not be covered by a service plan.
Is a house warranty required when purchasing a new home?
Marzen: If it's a brand-new home with brand-new appliances, the demand isn't as acute as it is with a pre-owned property.
Typically, sellers will provide at least one year of house warranty coverage for an incoming buyer since it gives the buyer peace of mind. In many circumstances, the seller will include this as a stipulation, or a Realtor would add it as a bonus.
$400–$800/year
The sum you are likely to spend for a house warranty.
Do you have an idea of how much a house warranty will cost?
Home warranties may cost hundreds of dollars every year. Pricing might range from $400 to $800 per year or more, depending on the type of coverage purchased.
A service call charge is frequently added to the annual cost of a home warranty. Every time a homeowner phones the firm for assistance, for example, if their heating system needs to be inspected, the home warranty provider will charge a service call fee.
A homeowner may pay $500 for their yearly warranty, but each time they call the firm for service, it may cost anything from $50 to $100. This cost will differ from one firm to the next.
Are house warranties a smart investment? Are they worth the money a homeowner would spend for them?
This, of course, varies from scenario to situation. If a person has the finances to self-insure their appliances, a home warranty may not be as important as if you are on a particularly tight budget and predict that an appliance will be in its last year, two, or three of operation.
It may be more cost-effective for the consumer to have a home warranty to give peace of mind. As a result, the topic of house warranties boils down to your risk tolerance for huge costs. Some homeowners forego house warranties entirely in order to preserve the money they would have paid out in the event of a future repair.
Do warranties often have an annual or lifetime restriction on how much they will pay?
Yes. Some warranties include a limitation of responsibility clause. A limitation of liability clause in a contract stipulates that the corporation is only required to pay up to a particular cash amount every year. Some of these provisions, diverse example provisions, were analyzed in a law review paper two or three years ago.
This threshold maybe $1,500 in some circumstances. It varies from business to company, but if a customer is considering purchasing a house warranty, they should check into it or contact the firm about it.
What are any other issues?
In some cases, a consumer's claim may be refused, and denials are a source of anxiety for many customers. These denials might be based on a variety of factors, but the most typical is the policyholder's lack of proper documentation for the appliance's upkeep.
Maintain records of all services performed, including yearly maintenance. Otherwise, faulty maintenance might be used to justify the refusal.
Companies will sometimes refuse to cover equipment that has rust or corrosion. Another difficulty might arise when the homeowner is unable to select the professional that comes out to assess or check the item.
Another issue that may arise is service speed. Companies make every effort to get a professional to the home as soon as possible, but service delays are not unusual.
Before coverage begins, most house warranties require a 30-day waiting period.
Is there usually a waiting period before receiving home warranty coverage?
Marzen: It depends on the circumstances. The waiting time may be avoided if you obtain a warranty as part of a real estate deal. A 30-day waiting period would not be exceptional in any other case. Some businesses will give coverage immediately.
When you buy a home warranty, you must guarantee that all of the appliances covered are in good working order and have no problems. If you lie, you may be charged with insurance fraud. It's the same as house insurance fraud. If someone warrants that something works and it doesn't, that is fraud.
If you misrepresent about the condition of equipment or systems, you might be charged with insurance fraud.
So, to summarize, what are some of the most essential advantages and disadvantages of house warranties?
One significant advantage is peace of mind. A house warranty contract gives security. Even while warranties are not insurance like typical homeowners insurance, they function similarly.
Some of the disadvantages we highlighted before, such as liability restrictions and the likelihood of claim denial, would be negatives.
Is there another option to purchase a home warranty contract?
One option is to self-insure. Another option is to check with your homeowners' insurance carrier to see if they have a mechanical breakdown endorsement. You might be able to secure an endorsement on your homeowner's policy to cover anything like an AC breakdown.
Of course, this would come at an additional expense. Major appliances such as air conditioners and furnaces are typical items covered under equipment breakdown coverage.
What factors should homeowners or customers consider while purchasing house warranty coverage?
Certainly, the state of one's equipment. Again, it comes down to your risk tolerance. If you can obtain low-cost equipment breakdown coverage through homeowners insurance, it may be more cost-effective for certain homeowners than a home warranty.
In some cases, the appliances may already be covered by an existing components warranty. Home warranties only cover functioning equipment. They would be disqualified if the appliances did not operate.
How to File a Complaint If You Believe You Have Been Duped
Who protects consumers, especially when the state excludes house warranties from the insurance commission?
In the past, state attorneys general have examined charges of unfair and misleading acts in connection with the warranties. In most states, some statutes protect consumers.
They are protected under unfair and deceptive practices (UDAAP) legislation. A UDAAP claim would be filed if a corporation engaged in widespread claim denials without an appropriate basis. You can also contact your state's attorney general, the consumer protection division, or the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB).
Hiring an attorney might be difficult since the cost of an attorney can often surpass the amount of the claim. In comparison to regular insurance, home warranty claims are often lower. That is why the attorney general's office and the state consumer protection authority provide remedies.
Small claims court is another option for consumers who believe they have been harmed. The consumer may be entitled to represent oneself in small claims court, depending on the state.
Is it necessary for a consumer to have legal representation in any of these matters, save maybe small claims court, or can you make a complaint without legal representation?
In the case of the attorney general, the complaints might be written by an attorney or come straight from the individual. In any court matter, whether small claims or otherwise, it is prudent to acquire legal representation. If you have a claim, you should consult an attorney before submitting it.
To be clear, one includes seeking counsel or going to an attorney for assistance. The second option is to have your attorney accompany you to court.
Correct. Even before going through the small claims process, it's a good idea to obtain advice since an attorney may very likely handle it in small claims.
Attorneys often appear in small claims courts in various jurisdictions. It is less frequent in other states.
How to Select a Best Home Warranty
In terms of assisting the typical customer, you've produced a handful of law review papers on house warranty difficulties. What are some of their options?
Compare the costs of various plans. Examine the company's Better Business Bureau rating. How do customers perceive the company? Conduct web research to see how that company's consumers feel about the product.
Do your homework, whether it's through the Better Business Bureau, internet research, or asking questions of the firm. "What is the scope of this contract?" "Does liability have a limit?" These kinds of inquiries are crucial.
Is there anything we didn't cover in our discussion on house warranties?
In general, I believe that keeping documents is an excellent idea for homeowners. Maintain records for both appliances and systems. Keep track of any warranties that are still in effect.
Check to see whether you obtained an additional year warranty from the credit card company if you paid using a credit card. Consider homeowners insurance endorsements or self-insuring.
